How Can Coffee Producers Prevent Another Benecke? (COMSA & Peruvian Cooperatives) - EP1145 Part 5 of 5 (Map It Forward)
Advertising Sponsor
This episode is brought to you by CoffeeListings.com, by Map It Forward - the marketplace where the coffee world does business. Find or list coffee, equipment, services, jobs, businesses, wanted ads, and other opportunities across the global coffee industry. www.coffeelistings.com
Episode Description
This is part 5 of a new 5-part series on The Daily Coffee Pro Podcast by Map It Forward, hosted by Lee Safar. Our guests are Rodolfo Peñalba, General Manager of COMSA in Honduras, his colleague Olvyn Hernandez, and Óscar Inocente, a lawyer working with four Peruvian cooperatives affected by the Benecke Coffee insolvency. Pedro Manga joins Lee as co-host and Spanish translator.
This is our fourth series covering the Benecke case, focusing on the fight to get coffee producers paid.
After examining the unpaid coffee, the financial consequences and the struggle to recover millions of dollars, we conclude by asking how the coffee industry can prevent similar situations in the future.
Rodolfo explains why COMSA is reconsidering the risks it accepts when trading internationally. With more potential buyers available, the cooperative is increasingly prepared to walk away from business if a buyer's financial position presents unacceptable risks.
Óscar agrees. For the Peruvian cooperatives, declining a sale is preferable to delivering coffee and never receiving payment.
The discussion also examines the wider responsibilities of buyers, the role of Fairtrade and commercial safeguards, and whether existing protections adequately reflect the realities faced by coffee producers.
Rodolfo raises questions about the future of J.J. Darboven's Café Intención brand and the sourcing of substantial volumes previously supplied by COMSA through the Benecke relationship.
He also challenges the industry to consider an important distinction: even when something is legally permitted, does that necessarily make it fair?
As the series concludes, Lee and Pedro encourage coffee businesses to engage directly with the affected cooperatives and explore opportunities to build responsible commercial relationships.
The central message is clear: producers should not have to risk their financial survival simply to participate in international coffee trade.
Connect with our guests:
Rodolfo Peñalba and COMSA: https://www.linkedin.com/company/comsaofficial/
https://www.instagram.com/comsa_oficial/
Olvyn Hernandez: https://www.linkedin.com/in/olvyn-hernandez-5b9269256/
Óscar Inocente: https://www.linkedin.com/in/oinocente/
Peruvian Cooperatives Media Manager - Marcafab: https://www.linkedin.com/company/marcafab
Catch up on our previous Benecke coverage:
Series 1 | Peru: The experiences of affected Peruvian cooperatives: https://www.mapitforward.coffee/podcasts/daily-coffee-pro-benecke-coffee-1656
Series 2 | Honduras: COMSA's experience and the impact on Honduran producers: https://www.mapitforward.coffee/podcasts/daily-coffee-pro-benecke-coffee-comsa-1661
Series 3 | The Benecke Case Explained: Lee Safar reviews the situation, evidence and outstanding questions: https://www.mapitforward.coffee/podcasts/daily-coffee-pro-lee-safar-solo-benecke-1666